We aim to carry as many different collectible products as possible. This includes many trading card games, sports cards, protective materials, and more!

It is a feature on the website that allows you to create a list of your cards to trade/sell to us. The Buylist will also show you the value of your cards in store credit or cash.

At this time we do not offer preorders for any products.

Please check our events tab for all upcoming activities.

All of our items are final sales, no items can be returned, exchanged, or refunded.

Every $1 spent will earn 5 points. Every 100 points equates to $1 to spend at The Nostalgic Knick Knack. You must have an account created with an active email to earn and access your points.

You must activate your account on our website with your email to view and redeem points. You may redeem your points on your account instantly or we are more than happy to help in the store.

Max Insured Value is the highest dollar amount you estimate each individual submitted item will be worth after PSA authentication and grading. In the case that your items are damaged, during PSA processing or shipping, this is the maximum amount you may receive if a claim is needed. The actual payout amount will be determined on the severity of damage or loss and is always limited to the item's fair market value.

No, you may submit to any grading company with a personal account of your own! We do offer PSA grading services if you would like us to assist in the process.

We ask that all cards are in a penny sleeve first and then are carefully inserted into a semi-rigid card holder. PSA recommends the Card Saver 1 as the best card holder to submit in. Please do not add any tabs, notes, or additional materials to the cards being submitted. We will assist with the packaging to ship out your submission.